| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Casper Cutthroats | Casper, Wyoming | Mountain Collegiate Baseball League | amateur | active |
| Denver Cutthroats | Denver, Colorado | Central Hockey League | professional | defunct |
| Northern Colorado Cutthroats | Windsor, Colorado | Premier Arena Soccer League | amateur | active |
| Queen City Cutthroats | Helena, Montana | Northern Pacific Hockey League | amateur | defunct |
| Sun Valley Community Cutthroats | Sun Valley, Idaho | high school | active |